|
|
CJAC ARMS BOOK REVIEWS The following titles in an area of interest to arms collectors and historians, have recently been published. The publisher's address has been include and they may be purchased through your bookseller or direct from the publisher. They are not available from Museum Restoration Service.
by
Richard J. Garrett.
Imperial
German Edged Weaponry, by Ltc. Thomas M. Johnson. Imperial
German Edged Weaponry, by Ltc. Thomas M. Johnson. Imperial
German Edged Weaponry, Volume Three, by Ltc. Thomas M. Johnson.
Firearms
of the Royal [Swedish] Armouries II by Nils Drejholt.
by
Robert Douglas Smith. One
Hundred Years of by
Ray T. Giles & Daniel L Shuey. by
Mack A. Pattarozzi. by
Joel Black, Kerry Guerin by
Norbert Llups. The
History of Sniping and Sharpshooting by
John L. Plaster. Collector’s
Guide to by
James D. Brown Landeszeughaus
Graz Austria by
Robert E. Brooker.
Irish
Gunmakers by Richard J. Garrett. Self published, 2 La Hacienda, 27 Mount Kellett
Rd., The Peak, Hong Kong, China. 74 pp., 8¼x6 inches, soft cover, eight
illustrations, ISBN 978-988-17330-1-6. UK£10.00 postpaid. (Approximately
US$20.00) It
is more than 50 years since the last listing of Irish gunmakers was published,
compiled by M.S.D. Westropp, in the Journal of the Arms and Armour Society, and this latest title will
be of considerable value to the collector of antique British firearms.
Richard Garrett has built on this with 34 pages listing alphabetically,
the names, addresses, available dates, and background material when available,
along with a record of auction or internet sales of Irish-marked arms. He has
also brought together names from articles in lesser known journals, periodicals
and books. This listing is
preceded by an introduction to the trade in Ireland and followed by a listing of
gunmakers arranged alphabetically by town or village. Imperial German Edged Weaponry,
Volume One, Army and
Cavalry by Ltc.
Thomas M. Johnson. 12x9 inches, 450+
ills. Shiffer Publishing Ltd., 4880 Lower Valley Rd., Atglen, PA . 230pp., 11x8½
inches, 230 illustrations, ISBN 978-0-7643-2936-0
HC, $79.95. Imperial
German Edged Weaponry, Volume Two, Naval Dirks and Sabers
by Ltc. Thomas M. Johnson. 12x9 inches, 200+ ills. Shiffer Publishing Ltd.,
4880 Lower Valley Rd., Atglen, PA . 230pp., 11x8½ inches, 230 illustrations,
ISBN 978-0-7643-2935-7 HC, $79.95. Imperial
German Edged Weaponry, Volume Three, Automobile & Aero Corps, Government
and Civilian, Hunting, Colonial Kinder by Ltc. Thomas M. Johnson..
12x9 inches, 400+ ills., Shiffer
Publishing Ltd., 4880 Lower Valley Rd., Atglen, PA . 230pp., 11x8½ inches, 230
illustrations, ISBN 978-0-7643-2936-4 HC,
$79.95. This
trilogy follows in the tradition of the past sets of books by Lt. Col. Johnson
with Victor Diehl and Thomas Wittmann, published by Shiffer Publishing; an
enormous collection of large, clear, contemporary photographs in b/w or color,
relating to the titles, combined with photographs of the subject arms, all
accompanied by lengthy descriptive captions. Volume
One, Chapter One following a brief history of sword manufacture in Germany from
the 1870s, the authors have produce and introduction to provide a record of the
“Swords of the German Army during the Imperial Era.” with almost 250 pages
of sword illustrations and the way they were worn. This is followed by Chapter
Two titled “The Edged Weapons of the German Cavalry” with similar
introduction and treatment. Volume
Two, Chapter Four provides a “History and Development of the German Naval
Dirk, 1848-1929” followed by almost 200 pages of photographs. The fourth and
last chapter in this volume provides an introduction to “The German and Weimar
Naval Saber” with 50 pages of illustrations. Volume
Three, as the title suggests, includes five chapters, each with the same brief
history followed by the usual photographic album: Chapter
Five, “Dress Daggers of the Imperial Automobile and Aero Corps” by Hermann
Hampe. Chapter
Six, “Government Agency and other Civilian Edged Weapons” by the main.
authors Chapter
Seven, “The Imperial German Hunting Sidearms” by Carl Righter, Chapter
Eight, “Imperial German Colonial Sidearms” by Andy Shoredits, Chapter
Nine, Kinder, by Andy Marz, that is
dress swords produced for children As has been said before, the thought which went into the production of these books is quite unusual and the publisher is to be commended. They have a heavy dust jacket but under that, the boards are covered with a duplicate laminated, color printed cover which will survive the frequent handling these heavy tomes will receive. They may now be added to the previous volumes, German Daggers of W.W. II and German Swords of W.W. II. For further information visit www.schifferbooks.com
Firearms
of the Royal Armouries II by
Nils Drejholt. Stockholm: The Royal Armoury–Livrustkammaren, Slottsbacken 3,
SE-III 30, Stockholm, Sweden. 373 pp., 9½x9 inches, 835 ills. ISBN
91-87594-32-3. Price 290(approx US$47.00)
SEK; 237 SEK overseas postage. Livrustkammaren
— the Swedish Royal Armoury, is one of the world’s truly great arms
museums. In earlier centuries,
before it became a museum, it was the repository for much of the Royal Arms
Collections and for more than a century has been a world leader in arms
research (in 1914 the first internatinal symposium “. This new title can be
added to the significant resource material available on the arms collections
in Sweden. The first volume in the series, also by Dr. Drijholt, the Chief
Curator and head of the Collections Department, recorded the Royal collections
from Gustave II Adolf (1573-1625) to Charles XIII (1748-1818). The
catalogue is organized chronologically and begins where Part I ended, with
firearms donated to the State from the armouries of King Karl XIV Johan
(1760-1844), King Oscar I (1799-1859), to King Gustaf VI Adolf (1882-1973),
and various private collections, to the 1870s when the decision was made to
establish a National Arms Museum, and lack of space which necessitated a move
of unrelated material to other museums and arms to Livrustkammaren
Firearms
of the Royal Armouries II is
a well illustrated, well documented text (in English) of the firearms at
Livrustkammaren, based upon the catalogues prepared by the original owners. It
is illustrated with almost 850 large, clear photographs, many of them in
color, with a lot of detail illustrations and a large number of gunmakers’
marks. The contents run the gamut from early snaphance muskets to the hunting
guns of the later kings.
Make
all Sure: The conservation and restoration of arms and armour. Edited
by Robert Douglas Smith. Basilisco Press, Hawthorne Cottage, Moorfield Road,
Leeds, LS12 3SE, England. 144 pp., 11½x8 inches, 155 b/w 73 colour ill.,
softcover, ISBN 0-9551622-0-3, UK£25 postpaid (approx US$50.00) In
2002, the first international conference on the restoration and conservation of
Arms and armour was held on the historically important island of Malta. It was
organized jointly by the Royal Armouries in Leeds and the Malta Centre for
Conservation and Restoration with assistance from the Palace Armoury, Valetta
and the International Association of Museums of Arms and Military History (IAMAM),
now ICOMAM, the International Council of Museums of Arms and Military History.
The publication was supported by Nineteen
papers were presented by specialists in their own fields of conservation and
these have been collected under the editorship of Robert D. Smith, former head
of conservation at the Tower of London and The Royal Armouries Museum in
Leeds. A
collection of 19 essays on relating to the preservation of arms and armour
covering the conservation of European and Japanese armour, firearms,
gunshields, painted shields, and archaeological material. Reports on the
analysis of arms and armour including gilded surfaces, crucible steels and
Viking swords by some of the leading authorities on the subject, are included.
The record of papers follows: Only
Skin deep: surface coatings on arms and armour
by David Starley; Historic Techniques
for the gilding of armour by Kilian Anheuser; Historic
techniques for the gilding of armolur by Kilian Anheuser; Crucible
steel: Production and identification by Ann Feuerbach; Metallurgical examination of Viking-age sword blades to reveal their
pattern-welding technology; by Joachim Kinder, Martin Klein and Christian
Segebade; Aspects of the conservation
and restoration of archaeological arms and armour by
Marilyn Hockey and Fleur Shearman; The
conservation of the Wollaston Anglian helmet by Anthony Read; The
restoration of a 15th century ‘Gothic’ equestrian armour in the Wallace
Collection, London by David
Edge; The conservation of armour by
Douglas Smith; International rescue: An
Anglo-Maltese collaboration by
Suzanne J. Kitto; Different approaches
to the care of firearms by Alison Draper; The
storage and maintenance of weapons in the Palace Armoury, Malta, during the
17th and 18th centuries by
Stephen C. Spiteri; The conservation of
a gun-shield from the arsenal of Henry VIII, Textiles meets arms & armour;
the benefits of a multi-disciplinary research approach by Simon Metcalf,
Anthony R.E. North and Derek Balfour; The
restoration of medieval painted shields in the Metropolitan Museum by
Stuart W. Pyhrr; The conservation of a
Japanese armour by Igor Ravbar; The
conservation and display of a Japanese armour from the Edo Period by
Llasse Mattila; A history of arms and
armour conservation at the Metropolitan Museum by Stuart W. Phyrr; Metals conservation at the Royal Armoury in Stockholm by Lisen Tamm;
The armourers’ chest— Looking after
armour in the 17th century by Ruth Rhynas Brown; Through a glass darkly by Guy M. Wilson Colour plates. This
important series of papers covering most areas of interest to museums and arms
collectors should be in every museum conservators’ library.
Credit Card payment is not available. For ordering contact smithbrown@basiliscoe.fsnet.uk
One
Hundred Years of Winchester Cartridge Boxes, 1856-1956
by Ray T. Giles & Daniel L Shuey. Schiffer Publishing Ltd., 4880 Lower
Valley Rd., Atglen, PA 19310. 312 pp., 11x8½ inches, over 1,400 illustrations
(all color) ISBN 0-7643-2541-8. $69.95
(V/MC) It
is safe to say that no more handsome book has ever been produced for cartridge
collectors than this new publication released by Shiffer. Ray Giles and Dan
Shuey have put together a comprehensive “encyclopaedia” covering 100 years
of the evolution of Winchester cartridge boxes. Each box is illustrated with
large, clear, color illustrations of the full box and where needed, larger
illustrations of the details which differentiate different printings. Each is
accompanied by a descriptive caption (un-numbered) and an estimated value. Following
an introduction which covers box condition, rarity, value and photography, the
authors have produced an overview which discusses box construction and box
types to provide a terminology for collectors of all cartridge box
manufacturers. As they relate to Winchester products, they have identified
labels by color and have been able to produce a chronological sequence as the
first step in identification. In
addition, this chapter includes data on production code markings, date stamps,
paste-on overprint labels, file codes, perforated “dot codes,” etc. Chapter
2 deals with Volcanic cartridge packaging and Chapter 3 deals with Henry and
Winchester Model 1866 calibers. Thereafter, chapters are organized first, by
the model year of the rifle which introduced a caliber (and succeeding models
in the same category) and then by caliber within those models.
Each is preceded by an illustration and brief history of the rifles.
Chapter 4, for example covers the Models 1873, 1892, 53, 65, and 43, with
packaging for the caliber 218 Bee, .22 Hornet, .22RF, .25-20 W.C.F., .32-20,
.38-40 and .44-40. The .22 W.C.F. is also discussed but only a catalogue entry
survives to indicate that it was ever produced. Chapter
4 to 15 cover the Model 1876; The Hotchkiss Rifle, Model 1883; Model 1885
Single Shot; Model 1886, 71; Models 1894, 55, 64; Model 1895; Lee Straight
Pull Rifle; Models 1905, 1907, 1910; Model 36; Models 54, 70, 88; Chapter 16
provides 14 pages on Winchester calibers produced by other manufacturers The
real meat of this book is the pages between one chapter introduction, and the
next chapter introduction. For example, illustrations of the boxes, in
chronological order—13 pages on the .44-40 with 70, large, clear, color
illustrations including details of significant characteristics. The value of
this book to both the Winchester collector and the general collector will be
tremendous. A Glossary and Abbreviations, a Bibliography, and an Index have
been included. The
quality of One Hundred Years is
typical of Schiffer books: good printing, good color, good paper and excellent
binding. It is a book which will be around for the next 100 years.
Luftwaffe
Gravity Knife by
Mack A. Pattarozzi. Shiffer Publishing Ltd., 4880 Lower Valley Rd., Atglen, PA
. 268 pp., 9x6 inches, 289 illustrations, ISBN 0-7643-2419-5 HC, $49.95. The
Lufwtwaffe Gravity Knife, more correctly named Fliegerkamppmesser, which
is loosely translated «Flyer’s-cutting knife» abreviated to FKm or
often erroneously titled Fakkschirmjägermesser, is a simple, all
stainless-steel knife with scales of wood and a 5 inch (12.7cm) blade. As the
title indicates, this is the story of a utility knife with a blade that is
stowed in the grip when not in use but when called upon, is, using only one
hand, immediately, avialable and securely locked in place Although
originally intended for the airforce (Luftwaffe), it was also adopted
by the army (Heer) and the navy (Kriegsmarine). It was
officially approved 24 May, 1937 for flight crews and paratroopers.
Mr. Pattarozi has handled the background of the role played by the
different services and the background of the organization of the German army
in considerable depth In
eleven chapters and eight appendices, the author has traced the history,
design, construction and use of the FKm. The reader will find the exploded
views (Appendix A); Variations and the Main Characteristics (Appendix B);
Classification and Markings (Appendix E); and the Glossary of Terms, (Appendix
G), Each will be especially useful
Tranter
Cartridge Firearms by Joel
Black, Kerry Guerin and Roger G. Michaud. Self published, available from Joel
Black, 11066 Spring Creek Rd., Blue Mounds, WI
53517. Phone 608-437-5353 joel_black@netzero.net
. 11x8½ inches, 294 pp., 394 ills., softcover. US$ 40.00. When
three specialist collectors get together to produce a book on their area of
specialization, the result, as in this case, has provided the best data
available on the line of cartridge revolvers made by William Tranter of
Birmingham, one of England’s most important 19th century gun makers. William
Tranter as born at Oldbury, near Birmingham, in 1816 and by 1839 was
established as a gunmaker in Birmingham. In 1849 he filed Registered Design
No. 2054, a legal registration one step below a patent, for a pepperbox
revolver action which probably did not reach production. In
1853 he patented his first revolver action covering the well-known “double
trigger” percussion revolver and continued with more than a dozen related
patents over the next couple of decades. Although his revolvers were extremely
well made, they are not as well known to gun owners. This in part is because
he supplied a lot of the components to the gun trade, those who would now be
considered his competition, and his name appeared on them only as a small WT
under the grips or some obscure part or as a simple brand on the frame. His
practice of leaving the top of the barrels blank, to be engraved by the
merchants who sold them, passes the credit by many of today’s collectors, to
others Tranter
Cartridge Firearms begins
with a brief background on the inventor and detailed drawings of the features
of his patents. This is followed by a most comprehensive series on the various
revolver and rifle designs produced by the company. Each is illustrated with
one or more large, high quality, color illustrations with a lengthy caption
recording the arm’s characteristics. To provide an indication of the amount
of space devoted to each, the chapters and model variations covered have been
followed by the first page number for each. They include:
a Tranter Family History—5; Sheath (Spur) Trigger Revolvers—10;
Model 1863 Revolvers—46; House Defence Revolvers—64; Model 1868
Revolvers—84; Saloon Pistols—148; Rook Rifles —182; Model 1878
Revolvers—204; Model 1879
—214; .577 Revolvers—228; Kynock/Schleund Revolvers—228; Annomalies—258;
Appendix 1, A note on Serial Numbering—284;
Appendix 2, Relative Rarity of Tranter’s Cartridge Models.—285;
Appendix 3, Data Sheets of component variations.—286. For
the record, the press run of this book, which was published by the authors,
was based upon the number copies considered to be about what would be
required. Orders should be sent to Joel Black. The price ($40.00) includes
shipping in the USA. Credit card
payment is not available; personal cheques or money orders should be addressed
to Mr. Black at the address above.
The
Drilling by Norbert
Llups. Shiffer Publishing Ltd., 4880 Lower Valley Rd., Atglen, PA . 230pp.,
11x8½ inches, 230 illustrations, ISBN 978-0-7643-2749-0
HC, $49.95. Multi-barrel
and guns with combination rifle and shotgun barrels are well known in the
muzzle loading period but it was not until the advent of breech loading in the
1870s and light-weight steel that “Drillings” came into their own. They
are now what are probably the most expensive sporting gun on the market and
most are made to order. This
new publication about the class was first printed in German, the language of
the originators, under the title Der
Drilling, Geschichte, Einsatz einer jagdlichen Universalwaffe.
After a brief introduction, Mr. Llups first discusses the two major
components: the lock mechanism and the breech mechanism in that order. The
key component, the lock, had special requirements which permitted the firing
of three barrels one at a time in the order of choice. The earliest were built
on shotgun-like side-hammer guns with locks no more sophisticated than its
muzzle loading ancestor. The author has recorded, using spectacular
illustrations, progress through the Blitz lock system, Anson locks, side
locks, Nimrod box lock, and Fückert Crown locks. The
first breech patent was issued in Germany to Peter Oberhammer under date of 3
February 1878 and since then it has been under constant change and
improvement. Chapter IV titled Breech Systems, details these changes and in
sub chapters describes and illustrates The Lefaucheux Breech, the T Breech,
Bolt breeches, the Kersten breech, the Schüler Herkules breech, the Brenneke
breech, the patent of Franz Jäger, Thieme & Schlegelmilch, Texchner &
Collath, Emmanuel Meffert of Suhl, Robert Schrader, Burkhard Behr, and the
drillings from Ferlach. Most
Drillings are now produced in the factories of Krieghoff, Sauer & Sohn,
Suhl, Heym, Blaser, Antonio Soli, or Mathelon. But there are custom gunmakers
who will produce on special order and these have been covered in some detail
with illustrations of their work and special features they will incorporate
into their guns. Further
chapters are devoted to engraving, components, the butt, sights, insertion (subcaliber)
barrels, telescopic sights and mounts, buying used drilling, shooting in .223,
and the care of a drilling. The
author of The Drilling/Der Drilling,
Geschichte and Shiffer publishing have produced a book of quality that
will stir the imagination of gun lovers at all pocket book levels.
The
History of Sniping and Sharpshooting
by John L. Plaster. Paladin Press, 7077 Winchester Circle, Boulder,
CO. 80301. 704 pp., 8½x11 inches, 700 (+/-) ills., hardcover, ISBN
978-1-58160-632-4. US$89.95. Although
there are a number of books on the craft of the sniper, this is the first in
depth study of the subject by a former instructor and long-time student of the
history. Maj. John Plaster, USAR (Ret.) began collecting material on the
history of sniping more than 25 years ago and on business trips it was a
second project. He was an overseer at the European sniping championships in
the Czech Republic, studied at the Austrian Military Museum, attended the Fort
Benning Army Sniper School, and is the author of The
Ultimate Sniper, a book about Russian snipers and their tactics. Most
books on sniping concentrate in WW1 and WW2, with extensive coverage of the
rifles and equipment, and little else. This
one does not neglect the artifacts but there is considerable on the men who
used them and the men who they were used on. The History of Sniping and
Sharpshooting has been
presented in six parts: 1.
Early Wars in the New World and on the Continent; 2.
The American Civil War; 3.
Sharpshooting in Transition. 4.
Two World Wars: 5.
The Asian Wars; 6.
Sniping in the 21st Century. Part
one takes the reader back to the very early history of rifling, how and why it
was important, and gives a running history of it during the French and Indian
Wars period. An interesting feature
of this chapter, and indeed the whole book, is that occasionally an excerpt, or
an aside, or what in a newspaper might be called a side-bar, or a block of text
set in a different font on a grey screened background — a half page or a full
page of text with a related story, or a piece of a story designed to provide
background to the main story. Examples of this feature is the story of
“Captain Jack, the Black Rifle” or “Rogers Rangers’ Standing Orders”
of “Sharpshooters in the Rigging.” Good
reading, the stuff from which heroes and legends are made. Major
Plaster has produced a book which is a good read that will serve as an excellent
reference, and Paladin has produced a fine history book with a large number of
good, clear, and appropriate illustrations.
Collector’s
Guide to Imperial Japanese Handguns 1893-1945 by
James D. Brown. Schiffer Publishing Ltd., 4880 Lower Valley Rd., Atglen, PA
19310.64 pp., 11x8½ inches, 59 ill., softcover, ISBN 978-0-7643-2787-2.
US$19.95. This
new volume has been prepared as an inexpensive guide to Japanese military
handguns of the first half of the 20th century.
It is intended primarily for the collector who, upon encountering a new
specimen, wants information to identify, classify and evaluate it in order to
make a decision on its purchase. It
will also be useful to dealers in establishing values, and to firearms owners
who simply want to know where a individual pistol or its accessories fit in the
overall picture of Japanese military collectibles.
There are 59 large, clear, illustrations along with translation aids for
the markings
Landeszeughaus
Graz Austria Wheellock Collection
by Robert E. Brooker. Graz:
Landesmuseum Joanneum, Herrengasse 16, 8010 Graz, Austria. 736 pp., 12x8½
inches, 2,800+ illustrations, ISBN 978-0-9795532-0-2. Price €65 (approx.
US$97.00); surface post €26, air, €38. (Visa/MasterCard) The
Landeszeughaus in Graz, capital of the province of Styria in Austria, is the
only complete 17th century military arsenal which has survived. It was the
store-house and workshops for the armour and arms purchased during the 16th to
18th century and is now the museum where more than 4,000 wheel-lock firearms are
displayed or stored. In this
important new book, Robert Brooker, assisted by a team of museum employees, has
created a masterly, detailed study of the collection at a level never before
accomplished. Dr. Leopold Toifl has provided a history of the Landeszeughaus in
German with an English translation and Dr. Brooker has provided the catalogue
descriptions, in English only. His
introduction to the catalogue provides an overall view of the design, evolution,
production, acquisition, use, and decoration in a unique opportunity to study
each in a single collection covering the late 16th century through the middle of
the 17th century. This
is followed by the chapters: Early Wheellocks, 1510-1550; Decorated Military
Wheellock Pistols, 1566-1600; Transition Period, 1600-1630, from costly puffers
to plain military pistols; Military Wheellock long guns; Undecorated Military
Wheelock pistols 1620-1700; Civilian Wheellocks in the Landeszeughaus; Basic
Wheellock designs which carried over into flintlock pistols by virtue of a
change in the lock. Although many accessories are incorporated into the body of
the catalogue, a fifty-page ‘appendix’ also deals with wheellock
accessories. (including priming flasks, 1580-1590s; Cartridge boxes, Augsburg;
Cartridge boxes, Nürnberg; Puffer holsters; Wheellock spanners; Priming flasks;
Bandoliers; Musket rests; Sabers with cartridge box/scabbards; Musket powder
flasks; Wheellock holsters, and
Bullet moulds) The
catalogue portion is a photographic record (more than 3,800 of them, in colour),
of pistols, guns, and rampart or wall-guns.
Most are presented with four views but a large number have additional
views with as many as nine details. An important contribution is the large
number of gunmakers’ marks and guild marks. These are hardly ever presented
photographically and the accuracy of the artistic rendering is often in
question. Production
of The Landeszeughaus Wheellock Collection
catalogue has provided a service to the fraternity which is seldom seen.
The large, clear, and high quality of the illustrations (all of the
collection is in colour), makes it unlikely that there will ever be a second
printing; the opportunity will not arise again.
Only 1000 copies were printed. (Phone +43-316-8017-9818; E-mail infopoint@museum-joanneum.at
|
| ||||||